| Past Grand Guardians | Year | Past Associate Grand Guardians |
|---|---|---|
| Angela Kindle, PHQ, #43 | 2024 | Chris Berg, #43 |
| Alison Bowzer, MM, #44 | 2023 | |
| Sarah Watson, PHQ, #49 | 2022 | Chris Smead, #7 |
| Katie Underwood, PHQ, #12 | 2021 | Chris Lindner, #12 |
| Paula Howard, #47 | 2020 | Jerry Arruda, #29 |
| Paula Howard, #47 | 2019 | Jerry Arruda, #29 |
| Judy Seitz,, #44 | 2018 | Jim Chaney, #5 |
| Linda Stokes, #47 | 2017 | Jody Kalel, #49 |
| 2016 | Randy Davis #4 | |
| Amy Kalal #49 | 2015 | Troy Whitton #7 |
| Judy Royce #47 | 2014 | Jim Kelly #29 |
| Julia Wallace #7 | 2013 | Gary Dryer #1 |
| Linda Meunier #43 | 2012 | Doug Anderson #44 |
| Kim Underwood #12 | 2011 | Joe Braun #36 |
| Sandy Flanery #33 | 2010 | Stan Johnson #60 |
| Joleyne Nelson #37 | 2009 | Vernon Carpenter #19 |
| Nancy Knarr #19 | 2008 | Craig Stratmann, #47 |
| Donna Goede, #43 | 2007 | |
| Helen Kramer, #25 | 2006 | Dennis Flanery, #33 |
| * Phyllis Boehme, #43 | 2005 | John Vezeau, #43 |
| Marcella Key, #40 | 2004 | John Brand, #3 |
| Toni Underwood, #12 | 2003 | Ralph Schmidt, #12 |
| Linda Sinley, #29 | 2002 | Randy Sinley, #29 |
| Jayne Wills, #65 | 2001 | * Bill Perry, #33 |
| * Mary Bunning, #37 | 2000 | Ron Crites, #3 |
| * Ruth Walton | 1999 | * Bob Hudson, #65 |
| Jan Lynch, #50 | 1998 | * Ted Cassens |
| Miss Linda Mosby, #42 | 1997 | Jeffrey C. Kitsmiller Sr., #47 |
| Anna Rhoads, #45 | 1996 | Earl Simpson, #32 |
| Diane Kitsmiller, #47 | 1995 | Tom Hennenhoefer, 49 |
| Virginia Kernes, #29 | 1994 | * Terry Thuet, #47 |
| Patti Brand, #39 | 1993 | Ashley H. Underwood, #12 |
| Susan Moulton, #40 | 1992 | * Richard Henderson, #43 |
| Beth McKnight, #24 | 1991 | * Earl Tisdale, #50 |
| Myrt Williams, #37 | 1990 | * Mel Mueller, #49 |
| * Marjory Callmeyer, #3 | 1989 | * James E. Snavely, #34 |
| * Wanda L. Toulouse | 1988 | Curry Sanders, #37 |
| * Ann Tisdale, #50 | 1987 | * Dick Holmes, #44 |
| * Nelda Kaeser. #1 | 1986 | * Edwin Andler, #52 |
| Beverly Wann, #46 | 1985 | * Bill Dinkmeyer, #37 |
| Sharon Simpson, #48 | 1984 | * Jack Mielke |
| * Edith Willmann | 1983 | * Jim Hardinger |
| * Betty K. Sandstedt, #44 | 1982 | * Lionel J. Goede, #43 |
| * Marlene E. Frakes, #33 | 1981 | * Ronald O. Bardol, #14 |
| Lynne Stratmann, #12 | 1980 | * Dan C. Peak |
| * Karen Jordan, #49 | 1979 | Bill Wann, #46 |
| Shirley Crosby Boyd, #63 | 1978 | * Kenneth Ireland |
| Ginny Goede, #43 | 1977 | * James Q. Harbison |
| Doris Mielke, #24 | 1976 | * Dr Albert Howe, #31 |
| * Miss Arline Schmidt | 1975 | * John Darcy, #59 |
| * Marie Nadler | 1974 | * Paul West |
| * Mildred Klasing | 1973 | * Howard F. Thiel |
| * Shirley Albright | 1972 | * Roy Partenheimer |
| * Betty Mueller, #21 | 1971 | * Albert Powell |
| * Nancy Toner | 1970 | * Charles Chaney |
| * Florence Gerwiner | 1969 | * Roy Fleming |
| * Oralee Beffa, #12 | 1968 | * Francis Rudd |
| Edleen Ireland | 1967 | * James E. Bryan |
| * Hope Blumenberg | 1966 | * Wesley C. Kreh |
| * W. Peggy Zimmer | 1965 | * Ernest F Erler, #21 |
| * Lela Meyers Ham | 1964 | * Russell Ochsenknecht |
| * Ruth Akin | 1963 | * Robert Leavitt |
| * Pearl Russell | 1962 | * Allen Goodman |
| * Mary Lou Biggs | 1961 | * Elmer Kuehn |
| Ina Jane Bryan, #38 | 1960 | * Wilbur Gebaur, #39 |
| * Josephine Harvey | 1959 | * Edward Zimmer |
| * Mildred Erler, #21 | 1958 | * Claude Noecker, #31 |
| * Idakatherine Schenk, #14 | 1957 | * Alfred E. McDanel |
| * tie Standish | 1956 | * Wallace Daugherty |
| * Winifred Mastin, #31 | 1955 | * Judge Reginald Smith |
| * Anne Brown | 1954 | * Leo Atenhofer |
| * Hariet Ruth Kreh, #14 | 1953 | * Paul Schmidt |
| * Margaret Thacker | 1952 | * Fred Ehrhardt |
| * Ruth Mary Leavitt | 1951 | * Vernon Roloff |
| * Dollie Knoll | 1950 | * Gustave Knecht |
| * Martha Gatzert | 1949 | * Herman Kost, #21 |
| * Nina M. Lee | 1948 | * Charles C. Kratz |
| * Muriel Ottman | 1947 | * Edgar Wood, #6 |
| * Virginia Mills, #14 | 1946 | * Edward Landingham |
| * Irene D. O'Brien | 1945 | * William E. Punt, #12 |
| * Olsee Gardner | 1944 | * Alfred Becher |
| * Louise M. Achilles, #6 | 1943 | * Dr Harry F. C. Meyer |
| * Augusta Price | 1942 | * Robert Fulton |
| * Margaret Ross | 1941 | * Thomas F. Thiel |
| * Bertha M. Key | 1940 | * James U. Rickerdd |
| * Vera J. Owens | 1939 | * B.A. Feldman |
| * Gladys Morrisseau | 1938 | * Ferdinand H. Binder |
| * Aileen Card, #6 | 1937 | * Charles R. Sackman |
| * Elizabeth Patrick | 1936 | * Charles E. Hummer |
| * Florence Von Arx | 1935 | * Dr William Segraves |
| * Berenice Kreh | 1934 | * M. M. Ohler |
| * Clara Beckman | 1933 | * Paul Anthes |
| * Laura Dixon | 1932 | * Max Loewen |
| * Flake Piney Ohler | 1931 | * Frank Palmer |
| * Mildred Westermann | 1930 | * Charles Kreichelt |
| * Addie J. Peters | 1929 | * William Schawacker |
| * Miss Louise Reinhardt | 1928 | * Edwin R. Fryer |
| * Grace Trail | 1927 | * John B. Bush |
| * Clara Fletcher | 1926 | * Merle E. Cambell |
| * Miss Ella K. Falkenheimer | 1925 | * George Lohmeyer |
| * Miss Harriet E. McArthur | 1924 | * Herbert Dunham |
* Deceased